By Associate Professor Dongwon LEE, Department of Information Systems, Business Statistics and Operations Management, HKUST Business School

Digital transformation presents organizations with opportunities and challenges; fostering innovation and collaboration is key to creating lasting value for stakeholders.

In recent decades, the rapid rise of digital technologies has positioned digital transformation at the forefront of academia and industry. This phenomenon is not simply about adopting new technologies; it involves a fundamental change in how organizations operate, engage with customers, and deliver value. Digital transformation represents a significant change to an existing organization through digital technologies, distinct from digital innovation, which focuses on creating something new, and digital disruption which refers to the replacement of existing systems. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for organizations aiming to navigate the complex landscape of digital change effectively.

Understanding digital transformation

Digital transformation is characterized by several key aspects. First, it leverages cutting-edge technologies such as big data analytics, blockchain, the Internet of Things (IoT), and artificial intelligence (AI). These technologies offer capabilities and connectivity that far exceed what traditional IT systems can provide.1 Second, digital transformation transcends organizational boundaries, engaging with broader ecosystems and business networks. This cross-boundary approach allows organizations to create value not just internally but also across entire supply chains and customer bases. Lastly, digital transformation can lead to the emergence of new digital business models even in industries that are not inherently digital. By understanding these dimensions, organizations can better position themselves for successful digital transformation.

Successful digital transformation typically focuses on three key areas: customer experience, operational processes, and business models.2 Enhancing customer interactions is essential for organizations looking to build stronger relationships and drive loyalty. This can be achieved through customer analytics, digitally enhanced selling, and predictive marketing. Companies that excel in these areas often create personalized experiences that resonate with their customers, ultimately leading to increased satisfaction and retention. Operational processes are also vital in digital transformation. By digitizing processes, enabling remote work, and making data-driven decisions, organizations can significantly improve their operational efficiency. This shift not only reduces costs but also enhances agility and responsiveness to market changes. For example, organizations can leverage real-time data to optimize supply chains, streamline workflows, and better respond to customer demands. The ability to make informed decisions based on data insights is a key differentiator in today’s competitive landscape. Business models undergo transformation as well, allowing companies to innovate and adapt to evolving market conditions. Developing new digital products and services and reshaping organizational boundaries enables companies to explore novel revenue streams and value propositions. This might mean transitioning from traditional offerings to subscription-based models or creating platforms that connect users in innovative ways. For example, companies like Netflix and Spotify have successfully disrupted traditional media distribution models by leveraging digital technologies to offer on-demand content and personalized recommendations. These transformations illustrate how businesses cannot only survive but thrive in a rapidly changing environment.

At the industry level, digital transformation typically unfolds in three phases: the trigger phase, the experimentation phase, and the shakeout phase.3 The trigger phase is often driven by technological advancements, shifting consumer preferences, regulatory changes, or entrepreneurial activities. Organizations must recognize these triggers to initiate their transformation journeys effectively. During the experimentation phase, companies engage in trial and error to discover new competitive formulas. Many players compete using alternative technologies and standards during this stage, leading to a dynamic and often chaotic landscape. Finally, in the shakeout phase, a dominant pattern emerges often leading to the decline of organizations that fail to adapt. Companies that can successfully navigate this phase will secure their market positions, while those that do not may face significant challenges.

At the organizational level, digital transformation is seen as an iterative process comprising several stages. The first stage is defining value, where organizations clarify the value they aim to deliver through digital transformation. This involves aligning digital initiatives with overall business objectives and understanding how these efforts will create value for customers and stakeholders.4 The second stage is the launch and acceleration phase, where organizations implement initial changes and accelerate efforts based on early feedback. This phase may involve pilot projects or limited rollouts to test new digital solutions before a broader implementation. The third stage, scaling up, focuses on expanding successful models identified in the earlier phases. Organizations can concentrate on scaling these initiatives for broader impact, ensuring that lessons learned during the experimentation phase are applied effectively. Understanding these phases helps organizations plan effectively and allocate resources wisely as they embark on their digital transformation journeys.5

Driving digital transformation

Established companies often face unique challenges when pursuing digital transformation, especially when it involves disruptive innovations that require difficult trade-offs. For incumbents, assessing the impact of new technologies on existing capabilities is essential. They must determine whether a technology is competence-enhancing, improving existing capabilities, or competence-destroying, rendering current skills obsolete. This understanding will inform strategic decisions and resource allocation. Additionally, incumbents should evaluate the strategic significance of new technologies by asking the right questions of the right people. Engaging with fringe market customers, for example, can provide valuable insights into emerging trends and unmet needs. Organizations must also focus on creating initial markets through experimentation. This could involve piloting new products or services in niche markets before launching them on a larger scale. By identifying and developing these initial market opportunities, incumbents can mitigate the risks associated with digital transformation.

To succeed, established companies must be cautious of common pitfalls, such as delayed participation, sticking to familiar practices, reluctance to fully commit, and lack of persistence6. These traps can hinder progress and prevent organizations from seizing digital opportunities. Investing in expanding the organization’s peripheral vision and fostering a culture of learning is essential for identifying emerging trends and potential disruptions. By maintaining flexibility in their strategies, incumbents can adapt to changing market conditions and pivot when necessary. Additionally, granting autonomy to new ventures focused on emerging technologies is crucial for success. Allowing teams to operate independently fosters innovation and creativity, free from the constraints of traditional organizational structures. This autonomy empowers teams to experiment, iterate, and develop solutions that align with evolving customer needs and market dynamics.

New entrants, on the other hand, face distinct challenges in driving digital transformation, particularly regarding resource constraints and market positioning. New entrants must decide between two primary approaches: technical framing and market framing. Technical framing involves improving existing products or services using digital technologies to make them more appealing to mainstream customers. This approach requires anticipating competitive responses from incumbents and safeguarding intellectual property to maintain a competitive edge. Conversely, market framing focuses on identifying unserved or underserved customer segments that incumbents overlook. This strategy allows new entrants to carve out niches in crowded markets and establish themselves as viable competitors. For technical framing, new entrants should be prepared for competitive responses from established players and imitators. Protecting innovations and intellectual property is crucial to maintaining a competitive advantage in the marketplace. Additionally, engaging in ongoing innovation efforts can help new entrants establish temporary competitive advantages that can be leveraged for growth. For market framing, new entrants must address the liability of newness, which can hinder credibility and customer trust. Being attuned to environmental changes and stakeholder sentiments is vital for adapting strategies effectively. New entrants should also carefully evaluate social pressures and respond appropriately to maintain a positive brand image. By understanding the unique challenges they face, new entrants can position themselves for success in the digital landscape.

Insights from real-world cases

Real-world examples provide valuable insights into the principles of digital transformation. Home Depot’s $11 billion investment in improving online and in-store experiences showcases a commitment to enhancing customer engagement through digital means. By integrating digital technologies into its operations, Home Depot has been able to provide a seamless shopping experience that meets the evolving preferences of its customers. Similarly, Honeywell has demonstrated how established firms can innovate to stay relevant by digitizing internal processes and developing new digital offerings. This transformation has allowed Honeywell to streamline operations and enhance its value proposition to customers, ultimately driving growth in a competitive market. Microsoft’s transition from software licensing to cloud services under CEO Satya NADELLA illustrates another successful pivot in response to digital trends. By embracing cloud computing, Microsoft has positioned itself as a leader in the technology industry, offering scalable solutions that meet the needs of modern businesses. Conversely, Kodak serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of organizational inertia. Despite inventing the first digital camera, Kodak failed to adapt to the digital photography revolution, ultimately leading to its decline. This example underscores the importance of agility and foresight in navigating digital transformation.

In conclusion, digital transformation offers significant opportunities and challenges for organizations. As the business landscape rapidly evolves due to technological advancements, organizations must adopt a proactive approach to navigate this complex environment. Successful digital transformation goes beyond implementing new technologies, it requires a fundamental shift in how organizations think, operate, and engage with their stakeholders. Organizations must prioritize a culture of continuous learning and innovation, where experimentation is encouraged and failures are seen as learning opportunities. By embracing agility and adaptability, companies can remain resilient in the face of change, allowing them to pivot quickly in response to emerging trends and market demands. Furthermore, collaboration across departments and with external partners is essential to harness the full potential of digital transformation. By breaking down silos and fostering cross-functional teams, organizations can leverage diverse perspectives and expertise to drive innovation and create comprehensive solutions that address complex challenges. As businesses embark on their digital transformation journeys, they should also be mindful of the ethical implications of technology. Ensuring that digital initiatives align with sustainable practices and contribute positively to society is crucial for building trust with customers and stakeholders.

Ultimately, the path to successful digital transformation is unique for each organization, shaped by its specific context, goals, and challenges. Organizations that approach this journey with a strategic mindset, a commitment to innovation, and a focus on creating value for customers will not only thrive in the digital age but also shape the future of their industries. Embracing digital transformation is not merely an option; it is essential for organizational survival and sustained success in an increasingly digital world.

This article is adapted from and draws on the article “Driving Digital Transformation” by Dongwon Lee, Barney Tan, and Sunil Mithas (2023) in Digital Strategies and Organizational Transformation (pp. 27-49).

References

1. Mithas, S., Chen, Z. L., Saldanha, T. J., & De Oliveira Silveira, A. (2022). How will artificial intelligence and Industry 4.0 emerging technologies transform operations management?. Production and Operations Management, 31(12), 4475-4487.

2. McAffee, A., Ferraris, P., Bonnet, D., Calméjane, C., & Westerman, G. (2011). Digital transformation: A roadmap for billion-Dollar organizations. MIT Sloan Management Review.

3. Porter, M. E., & Rivkin, J. W. (2000). Industry Transformation. Harvard Business Publishing.

4. Saldanha, T. J., Lee, D., & Mithas, S. (2020). Aligning information technology and business: The differential effects of alignment during investment planning, delivery, and change. Information Systems Research, 31(4), 1260-1281.

5. Catlin, T., Lorenz, J. T., Sternfels, B., & Willmott, P. (2017). A roadmap for a digital transformation. McKinsey & Company.

6. Day, G. S., & Schoemaker, P. J. (2000). Avoiding the pitfalls of emerging technologies. California Management Review, 42(2), 8-33.