Being able to switch off from work is important for recovery and sustained performance, and organizations increasingly encourage employees to do so. But how do managers evaluate employees who follow this advice? Our research reveals a tension between what managers believe helps employees perform well and what they reward in promotion decisions.
Across a series of experiments, managers recognized that employees who disconnected from work during non-work hours would return more recharged, motivated, and productive. Nevertheless, these same managers considered them less deserving of promotion because they viewed detachment as a sign of lower commitment to work. This penalty persisted even among managers who themselves encouraged employees to disconnect and when employees had a compelling reason to do so.
We also found that an organization-wide policy limiting weekend email eliminated the penalty. While this is promising, a more lasting solution may require redefining commitment so that employees are valued for their contributions rather than their constant availability. Creating a workplace that truly supports recovery will require ensuring that employees can take a break without putting their careers at risk.